See More From Book Club Friends

Sign up and log in to post, comment and join the conversation.

Book Club Friends is 100% Canadian 🇨🇦

Peter Grainger
Luck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation
Book #3 of the DC Smith Investigation series
See the list of DC Smith Investigation books in order

Luck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation

When a worker goes missing from a North Sea gas platform, there seem to be just two possible explanations – it was a tragic accident or a suicide.

It does not take Smith and his detectives long, however, to discover that James Bell led a double life back onshore in Kings Lake, a life complicated enough to make him at least one dangerous enemy. Before the case can be unraveled, Smith must get a new team working together; Waters and Murray are still there but one of Wilson’s men is transferred to him, and the female detective constable from Longmarsh poses some unexpected problems for her new sergeant.

Together they begin to investigate the links between the companies and the people that bring ashore the oil and gas, and they also find themselves caught up in the seamier side of life that exists beneath Lake’s everyday comings and goings. Jo Evison begins to delve more deeply into the story of the Andretti murders, and Smith himself has to face the fact that he might no longer be considered fit for duty.

This, the third DC Smith investigation, follows on from ‘But For The Grace’.

Perfect for fans of Colin Dexter, Ruth Rendell, P D James, R D Wingfield or even John le Carre.

What readers are saying –

“As a dedicated fan of Peter Grainger’s work, I was delighted to find a third installment with this British detective ‘that looked most like an indifferently successful vacuum cleaner salesman’ according to one potential suspect. DC Smith is a warm, funny, intuitive detective who is relentless when chasing the truth and fearless in executing his duty.”

“This is a wonderful series – a police procedural with finely drawn and realistic characters. A real treat to read all of them.”

“My new favorite mystery author! Great character development, sharp wit and a good storyline.”

Author: Peter Grainger
Published: 2015
Page Count: 292

This page may include affiliate links.

Purchase on:

Amazon
Amazon

Book Club Discussion Questions For Luck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation

Luck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation
Discuss Luck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation With Your Book Club Friends

Do you want to take a deeper dive intoLuck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation? Chat about themes, characters, settings, plots and let’s celebrate this book for our Book of the Month discussion!

Suggest Luck and Judgement: A DC Smith Investigation

More Book Club Discussions

A Better Man
A Fatal Grace
A Great Reckoning
A Rule Against Murder
A Trick of the Light
A World of Curiosities
All the Devils Are Here
An Unfinished Love Story: A Personal History of the 1960s
Beautiful Ugly
Bury Your Dead
Glass Houses
How the Light Gets In
How to Stand Up to a Dictator: The Fight for Our Future
Iron Lake (20th Anniversary Edition)
Kingdom of the Blind
On Tyranny
State of Terror
Still Life
The Beautiful Mystery
The Boyfriend
The Briar Club
The Brutal Telling
The Crash
The Cruelest Month
The Frozen River
The Grey Wolf
The Housemaid
The Life We Bury
The Long Way Home
The Madness of Crowds
The Mighty Red
The Nature of the Beast
The River We Remember
The Rose Code
The Searcher
The Thursday Murder Club
Wild Dark Shore
See All Discussions

Highly Recommended Books by Peter Grainger Book Club Friends

Dance Hall of the Dead
Tie Dyed and Dead
Madame Tessier Knows All
Broken: A Novel
The Mistletoe Mystery: A Maid Novella
The King's Ransom
A Chateau Under Siege
The Black Cabinet
Blindsighted
King and Maxwell
Dance of Death
Judgment Prey
All That Is Hidden
The Forgotten
A Refiner’s Fire
Blue Monday
Bones Are Forever
Portrait of an Unknown Woman
In League with Sherlock Holmes
Airship
Falco: The Official Companion
The Shell Game: A Fox and O'Hare Short Story
The Harvey Girl
The Lying Game
Dead at First Sight
The Leper's Bell
End of the Pier
Send Bygraves
Death of a Hussy
The Truth: A DC Smith Investigation
Tea Time for the Traditionally Built
True Detectives
The Key to Rebecca
The Unlikely Spy
The Second Death
Pit Stop: Sean Reilly vs. Glen Garber
Going Wrong
Out of Range
The Body by the Sea: A Brittany Mystery
Whiteout
Hand of Evil
An Accidental Death: A DC Smith Investigation
Death with a Double Edge
The Scarpetta Factor
From Doon with Death
The Highway
Rabid: A Mike Bowditch Short Mystery
Silence in Hanover Close
Strange Affair: An Inspector Banks Novel
Friends are Forever
Growth Marks
Hunter's Moon
The Wife Upstairs
Missing Joseph
The Mephisto Club: A Rizzoli & Isles Novel
The Collector
A Place Called Freedom
Kisscut
The Cabinet of Curiosities
Fractured: A Will Trent Novel
Letters to a Soldier
Agatha Raisin and The Day the Floods Came
When the Music's Over
Want to Know a Secret?
The Devil's Cave
Dead Man's Grip
The Pharaoh Key
The Birthday Present
Death at the Sanatorium
Three Hands in the Fountain
Short Story: The MatchUp Collection
Q is for Quarry
Murder Unfolds
Tooth and Claw: A Longmire Story
The Hallmarked Man
Blacklight Blue
Heat Lightning
Killing the Shadows
The Fool's Run
The Survivors Club
The Face of a Stranger: A William Monk Novel
Death of a Green-Eyed Monster
An Evil Heart
Dead in the Water
The It Girl
Resistance
Storm Watch
Trouble
The Whole Truth
The 7th Month
The Caretaker: A Mike Bowditch Short Mystery
The Tale Teller
Coffin Road
Evan and Elle
Nine Perfect Strangers
A Christmas Gathering
Chaos
Shake Hands Forever
One Step Too Far
Breaking Point
The Talented Mr. Varg
The Last Ballad
The Janus Stone
Just One Evil Act
Lamentation
House of the Rising Sun
Eye of the Wolf
H is for Homicide
Past Reason Hated: An Inspector Banks Novel
In Dublin's Fair City
The Killing Stones
Fear the Worst
The Benefit of Hindsight
The Tree of Hands
A Private Cathedral
Uncommon Clay
Hung Out to Die
Still Life: A Karen Pirie Novel
Sacred Clowns: A Leaphorn and Chee Novel
The Best American Mystery Stories 2011
Watching You
Death in a Strange Country
Chrysalis
The Housemaid
A Sorrowful Sanctuary
The Murder of Mary Russell
A Breach of Security
Sovereign
Blood Money
The Monk Who Vanished
The Patriarch
Through the Window
A Darkness of the Heart
Point of Origin
The Long Ago
But For The Grace: A DC Smith Investigation
Christmas Mourning
For the Sake of the Game
Full Speed
The Rose Arbor
Blood from a Stone
Elevation
Name Withheld
Down Cemetery Road
The Risk of Darkness
Standing in the Shadows
The Solitary Friend
Blood in Eden
The Gifted
The Sacred Bridge: A Mystery Novel
Tunnel Vision
Spirit of Steamboat: A Longmire Story
Chinese Whispers
Killing Season: A Thriller
Ode To A Banker
Exit Music
A Fatal Grace
On Her Majesty's Frightfully Secret Service
The Kept Woman: A Will Trent Thriller
Moon Music: A Novel
The Stills
The Guest List
The Guy Who Died Twice
The Girl Who Died
Out of the Black Land
An Impartial Witness
The Executor: A Thriller
Watchman: A Novel
Twenty-one Days
The Late Show
The Prisoner of Castillac
A Dying Fall
Southern Discomfort
The Other Daughter
The Elusive Mrs. Pollifax
The Simple Truth
A Stranger in Mayfair
The Hunter
Portrait of a Spy
About Face
Take Out
Murder on the Red River
The Ice Limit
Brush Back
Other Worlds
The Uncommon Appeal of Clouds
Payment in Kind
The Neighbor
Never Say Die
Trouble Island
Dark of the Moon
The Hidden City
Framed in Fire
Return to Sender: A Longmire Mystery
Thief of Hearts
Girl Gone Missing
The Vanishing Box
So Sure of Death
Red Mist
The Laughter of Dead Kings: A Vicky Bliss Novel of Suspense
Blow Fly
In Like Flynn
Not Safe After Dark: And Other Stories
The Colors of All the Cattle
The Woman in the Water: A Prequel to the Charles Lenox Series
Transient Desires
Death of a Perfect Wife
Lord of the Silent
Cast Iron
The Winds of Change
The Purity of Vengeance
The Jackal's Head
I
Last Act in Palmyra
Dead Simple
Eye for an Eye
Deadline
A Death in Cornwall
Kiss Her Goodbye
The Understudy
When You See Me
Death of a Smuggler
Prom Mom
Cold Comfort: A Novella
Restless in the Grave
Victims: An Alex Delaware Novel
Vesuvius by Night
Blue on Black
The Night Hawks
Chosen Prey
The Fourth Sacrifice
The Surrogate Mother
The Devil's Code
Hornet's Nest
Half of Paradise
The Mysterious Bookshop Presents the Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2023
The Red Door
The Tightrope Walker: A Novel
Against the Grain
The Last Detective
A Twist of Fortune
Death of a Charming Man
Precious and Grace
The Devil's Bed
In the Electric Mist with Confederate Dead
Bruno
Silent Bones
The Proof of the Pudding
Death of a Poison Pen
Peril in Paris
Sleep No More: Six Murderous Tales
Brain Damage
Hasty Death
Bones: An Alex Delaware Novel
You Are Dead
The Woman in Suite 11
Birds of a Feather
A False Mirror
Death of an Eye
The Flood
Black Rainbow
Full Wolf Moon
The Lost Man
The Crash
The Last Word
The Mysterious Bookshop Presents the Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2024
Death of a Liar
Middlemen
Girl in a Box
A Faint Cold Fear
By Its Cover
Too Good to Be True
A Capitol Death
Postcards From the Mediterranean
Listen to Me
The Water's Lovely
Seven Corpses All in a Row
To Kill a Troubadour
The Vanishing Point
Give Unto Others
Blood Ties
The Weed That Strings the Hangman's Bag
Agatha Raisin and Tthe Haunted House
Quitter's Inc.
Dead by Dawn
Void Moon
A Christmas Vanishing: A Novel
Tooth and Nail
Silent in the Grave
The River We Remember
Night Gate
The Vows of Silence
Keeper of the Bride
Broken Harbor
The Absent One
The Bone Garden
The Dark Vineyard
The Noble Path
Trophy Hunt
Love You Dead