See More From Book Club Friends

Sign up and log in to post, comment and join the conversation.

Book Club Friends is 100% Canadian 🇨🇦

Peter May
The Critic
Book #2 of the Enzo Files series
See the list of Enzo Files books in order

The Critic

“This is a mystery with Gaillac flavor to be savored”–Mystery Scene Magazine

“A finely crafted and surprising mystery” –Kirkus Reviews

The body of Gil Petty, America’s most celebrated wine critic, is found strung up in a French Gaillac vineyard, dressed in the ceremonial robes of the Order of the Divine Bottle and pickled in wine.

For forensic expert Enzo Macleod, the key to this unsolved murder lies in decoding Petty’s mysterious reviews, which could make or break a vineyard’s reputation.

As he digs deeper for the motivation behind the shocking crime, Macleod finds that beneath the tranquil façade of French viticulture lurks a back-stabbing community characterized by a deadly rivalry–and home to someone who is ready to stop him even if they have to kill again to stop the investigation.

Author: Peter May
Published: 2007
Page Count: 304

This page may include affiliate links.

Purchase on:

Amazon
Amazon

Book Club Discussion Questions For The Critic

The Critic
Discuss The Critic With Your Book Club Friends

Do you want to take a deeper dive intoThe Critic? Chat about themes, characters, settings, plots and let’s celebrate this book for our Book of the Month discussion!

Suggest The Critic

More Book Club Discussions

A Better Man
A Fatal Grace
A Great Reckoning
A Rule Against Murder
A Trick of the Light
A World of Curiosities
All the Devils Are Here
An Unfinished Love Story: A Personal History of the 1960s
Beautiful Ugly
Bury Your Dead
Glass Houses
How the Light Gets In
How to Stand Up to a Dictator: The Fight for Our Future
Iron Lake (20th Anniversary Edition)
Kingdom of the Blind
On Tyranny
State of Terror
Still Life
The Beautiful Mystery
The Boyfriend
The Briar Club
The Brutal Telling
The Crash
The Cruelest Month
The Frozen River
The Grey Wolf
The Housemaid
The Life We Bury
The Long Way Home
The Madness of Crowds
The Mighty Red
The Nature of the Beast
The River We Remember
The Rose Code
The Searcher
The Thursday Murder Club
See All Discussions

Highly Recommended Books by Peter May Book Club Friends

Kiss of the Bees
A Simple Deduction
Surfacing
Blacklight Blue
The Camel Club
Under the Dome
Serpentine: An Alex Delaware Novel
The Zig Zag Girl
Blonde Hair
The Return of Raffles
A Fearsome Doubt
How to Seal Your Own Fate
Blood Work
The Bone Code
Angels Flight
The Sacred Bridge: A Mystery Novel
Empress of the Seven Hills
The Vanishing Museum on the Rue Mistral
Swing
The Midnight Feast
A Duty to the Dead
The House of Unexpected Sisters
The Quiche of Death
A Faint Cold Fear
Cop to Corpse
The Vanishing Man
The Survivors
With This Ring: A Deborah Knott Short Story
The Minotaur: A Novel
Livid
The Defector
No Time for Goodbye
Never Saw it Coming
The Valkyrie Directive
The Full Cupboard of Life
The Lamorna Wink
For the Love of Mike
Birds of a Feather
Remains of Innocence
Dead Mountain
Too Close to Home
The Perfect Victim
Trespasser
The Dark Wives
Farriers' Lane
1999: An Allie Burns Novel
Invisible Girl
The Dark on the Other Side
Boar Island
Shadows Reel
Girl Missing
Breaking the Dark
Pitch Dark
Murder in My Backyard
The Silent Girl
We Are All Guilty Here
A Cry in the Night
We Begin at the End
An Unkindness Of Ravens
Suffer Little Children
Someone in the House
The Other Daughter
Trouble Island
Water Like a Stone
Denial
Trial by Fire
A Fatal Grace
Massacre Pond
The Deadly Dance
The Cabinet of Dr. Leng
Dead Simple
Act of Mercy
Knave of Diamonds
Disaster at the Vendome Theater
Rattlesnake Crossing
End of Watch
Beastly Things
The Secret of Spandau
A Judgement in Stone
The Codex
A Great Reckoning
Body of Evidence
The Sugar House
Sleeping in the Ground: An Inspector Banks Novel
Night in the City
In Plain Sight
Midnight Run
The Killing Doll
The Rising Tide
Blue Genes
Dark Storm Rising: A Kate Burkholder Short Story
Justice Hall
Mrs. Pollifax and the Whirling Dervish
High Country Fall
Bitterroot
Cell
Death of an Eye
Dismissed with Prejudice
Phantom Prey
Hung Out to Die
Two Graves
Here I Stay
Sick of Shadows
Dead Like You
Devil's Food
The Housemaid Is Watching
Birds of Prey
Hell Is Empty: A Longmire Mystery
This Is What Happened
Dead Land: A V.I. Warshawski Novel
Skinwalkers
Death at the Sanatorium
The Shell Game: A Fox and O'Hare Short Story
A Tangled Web
Watching Eagles Soar
Malice Domestic 1
Dark August
Corpus Christmas
Among the Wicked
Winter Prey
Dead Man's Chest
The Endless Knot
Murder on a Midsummer Night
Deception on His Mind
The Spider's Web
Unnatural Death
The Match
The Shattered Tree
The Way of the Bear: A Mystery Novel
The Web: An Alex Delaware Novel
Prom Mom
Choose Me
Black-Eyed Susan
Gun Games
A Shilling For Candles
Blue Monday
Death of a Witch
Silence in Hanover Close
Night Train to Memphis
The Murder Stone: A Novel of Suspense
Transient Desires
When Will There Be Good News
The Hunter
Mrs de Winter
The Simple Truth
A Christmas Garland
Simply Lies
A Death in Vienna
Tigerlily's Orchids
Four Funerals and Maybe a Wedding
Brat Farrar
The Girls in the Garden
The Last Temptation
The English Assassin
Full Tilt: A Novel
What's Left Behind
Breakup
Find Her
The Amersham Rubies
The Comforts of a Muddy Saturday
The Spook Who Spoke Again
Book of the Dead
Maisie Dobbs
Tall Oaks
The Luckiest Woman Ever
Cold Earth
3 Truths and a Lie
The Saturday Big Tent Wedding Party
Blood Lure
Death and Judgment
Uniform Justice
Earthly Delights
I Found You
Stay Hidden
The Nature of the Beast
I Shall Not Want
Insidious Intent
The Purity of Vengeance
White Fire
The Department of Sensitive Crimes
Looking Good Dead
The Devil's Seal
A Gathering of Secrets
The Madness of Crowds
The Seventh Sinner
Evans Above
Master of Souls
The Spy Coast
Oystercatcher
Long Road to Mercy
O is for Outlaw
The Last Ballad
Ammie
The Proof of the Pudding
Sacred Clowns: A Leaphorn and Chee Novel
The Beautiful Mystery
Star Struck
Abracadaver
A Calamity of Souls
Savage Run
Fortune and Glory
Bone Box: A Decker/Lazarus Novel
Critical Mass: A V.I. Warshawski Novel
A Darkness More Than Night
A Line to Kill
In the Dead of Night
An Old Betrayal
About Face
Away in a Manger
What Child Is This
Sweet
The Jupiter Myth
Three-Day Town
Hard Truth
Still Dead: A J.P. Beaumont Novella
Bethlehem Road
The God of the Hive
The Monk Who Vanished
The Mystery Guest: A Maid Novel
Made for Murders
The Black Book
The Bounty
Capital Crimes: A Novel
The Dead Will Tell
Killing Raven
In Farleigh Field: A Novel of World War II
Stay Close
Blind Descent
When the Music's Over
The Talented Mr. Varg
The Red Door
Homecoming: A Historical Mystery
A Morning for Flamingos
Unnatural Habits
Simisola
Gideon's Sword
Serpent's Tooth
All Shall Be Well
Motor Mouth
Snowflakes
All That Remains
The Cellist
The Bone Collection: Four Novellas
The Good Husband of Zebra Drive
Iron Lake (20th Anniversary Edition)
Victim 2117
Moriarty
No Cure for Love: A Novel
A Suitable Vengeance
The Long Way Home
The Fallen Man
What Rose Forgot
Bloodless
The Last Devil to Die
Wild Irish Rose
The Lighthouse
The Blackhouse
Troubled Blood
The House of Silk: A Sherlock Holmes Novel
The Firemaker
Harbour Street
The Lost Bird
A Spot of Folly
Saturnalia
Means of Evil and Other Stories
Windy City Blues: V. I. Warshawski Stories
One-way Tickets: A Case For Willows and Lane
One Of Us Is Dead
Last Act in Palmyra
Out of Range
Funeral in Blue: A William Monk Novel
The Perfect Husband
I Am the Only Running Footman
A Thief of Time
I Know a Secret: A Rizzoli & Isles Novel
On the Edge
The Face of a Stranger: A William Monk Novel
Through the Window
Desert Star
Bring Me Back
Down Among the Dead Men
Vermilion Drift
Union Jack
Keystone
The Black Cabinet
Parting Shot
You Will Never Be Me
In Like Flynn
Innocent Blood
Nightshade
The Tale Teller
Silent Night
The Limpopo Academy of Private Detection
Death of a Kingfisher
Need You Dead
Long Lost
The Overlook
No Fixed Line
The Truth About Melody Browne
Stagestruck